Thursday, February 9, 2012

Initial Reactions to the Pacquiao-Bradley Fight Agreement

Those of you who read last week's post about the Mayweather-Cotto fight know how pleased I was to hear of the agreement. As happy as I was in that case, I am equally bothered by the Pacquiao-Bradley fight.


Floyd Mayweather is like Lebron- the most talented at what he does, cocky, arrogant, constantly putting his foot in his mouth. It's easy to dislike Floyd, and whenever people get a chance to, media included, they do. People seem to love Manny Pacquiao, but it is Pacquiao who should have more boxing-related question marks surrounding him.  Pacquiao's image is what Mayweather's isn't; it's respectable, loving, a family man who goes to church and has no history of beating women, fighting his father, and cursing on national TV. In Pacquiao's time away form boxing he's an influential congressman in the Phillipines, passing laws to aid the poor, while Mayweather is out burning $100 bills and placing $50,000 bets on regular season NBA games.


It's not difficult to see why Mayweather is so despised and Pacquiao is so adored. But in their recent fight choices, it is Pacquiao, not Mayweather, who should recieve heavy criticism.  Regardless of which one of them is ducking the other (I'm not going to get into that), the fact is they aren't fighting each other and all we as fans can do is comment on who they are choosing to fight.


On one hand, Mayweather is choosing a very good, battle-tested fighter at a higher weight division. Miguel Cotto walks around upwards of 20 pounds heavier than Mayweather. With weight classes every 7 pounds that we have in modern boxing, moving up to fight a much bigger man is no small feat. For more on why I can't wait for this fight, check out last week's post on it.


On the other hand, we have Manny Pacquiao pulling a Rocky III move and fighting a hand-picked, setup fight. Barring a Space Jam-like dissappearance of Pacquiao's skills, Timothy Bradley has no shot at beating Manny Pacquiao. None. Unlike Mayweather, Pacquiao is fighting a smaller man and having Bradley move up a weight class. Pound-for-pound, there's an argument to be had that Bradley is as good if not a better fighter than Miguel Cotto, but they fight at weight classes 14 pounds apart and are both fighting guys who fight 7 pounds in between the two. Bradley has only fought at 147 pounds one time in his career and looked mediocre against a mediocre fighter. Ask Ricky Hatton how that turned out, it only brought him from on top of his game to ending his career in two fights. Not to mention Hatton was widely regarded as more successful at 140 than Bradley, even though they're both undefeated.  While he's a different style of fighter than Hatton, Bradley doesn't fit the blueprint for fighters who have a shot at beating Pacquiao that Juan Manuel Marquez provided for us last November. Marquez proved that if you can effectively counterpunch with power shots to keep Pacquiao from his getting off his lightning-quick flurries, you have a shot at beating him. Bradley a speed fighter with very little power even at 140 pounds.  He's like a glorified version of Paulie Malignaggi. Pacquiao has more speed and significantly more power than Bradley. Why would anyone think he has a shot at beating Pacquiao? Good luck promoting this one as a competitive fight.


There's only one person Pacquiao should be in the ring with, assuming working things out with Mayweather never stood a chance. Juan Manuel Marquez nearly beat Pacquiao but lost a tight decision for the third consecutive time.  Each one of their fights has been an instant classic. Unfortunately for us fans, these three fights have been spread out over almost 8 years. People call out Mayweather for not having that competitive dog quality that wants to always fight the best, but what kind of competitor gets cut up, nearly beaten, and then turns to a much easier opponent when Marquez has repeatedly stated he wants Pacquiao again? If he's really the best in the world as his fans believe, why is running away from not one but two great fighters and choosing a guy with next to no chance of winning? Shame on you, Manny Pacquiao, and shame on us fans for believing Pacquiao's diefied image.

Wednesday, February 1, 2012

Mayweather-Cotto

Dan Rafael reported via twitter that Floyd Mayweather has announced he will fight Miguel Cotto for Cotto's 154-lb title on May 5.  I may be in the minority, but I'm pumped. Sure, Cotto isn't Manny Pacquiao, but if you've read some of my previous posts on the topic, I never expected Floyd and Manny to come to an agreement for the May 5 date. Like I've said before, I do think they will fight at some point but it will be when they are both past their primes and need one last big-money fight. No matter how over-the-hill they are, Mayweather, the king of Pay-Per-View, and Pacquiao, with a whole island riding on his back, will always be monetary attractions. That fight could be made at any point and it will still be a huge payday.


Not only is Miguel Cotto the best fighter Floyd's fought since Jose Luis Castillo in 2002, but this is a perfect example of the old saying "styles make fights." I expect it to be highly entertaining because of the contradictory nature of the way Mayweather and Cotto fight. Cotto is a constant pressure fighter who uses his muscular build to his advantage, whereas Mayweather is a counterpuncher who draws his opponent in and uses his superior defensive skills and quick hands to his advantage. Cotto is known to "look like a middleweight", even when fighting as welterweight. He always appears to be the "bigger man" in his fights, even though he's fighting guys of the same weight. In laymans terms, he fights like a bully. Floyd is a very averaged-sized welterweight. Recently, Cotto's been fighting at 154 pounds- 7 pounds more than Floyd, which combined with Cotto's offensive style, could cause Floyd some serious problems. Floyd's never weighed in at more than 150 (once) for a fight, and even then he weighed 148 on fight night. Cotto will have a 5-7 pound weight advantage.

 Floyd's only fought one bigger man- a far past his prime Oscar De La Hoya in 2007. Floyd's only fought a few fighters that are as aggressive as Cotto is; Arturo Gatti (2005) and Ricky Hatton (2007) come to mind, but there is a major difference. Floyd was able to wear both Gatti and Hatton down before knocking them out in the 6th and 10th round, respectively. Gatti and Hatton continually charged forward and got picked off by Mayweather's unique ability to lead effectively with his jab, straight right, and left hook. Neither Gatti or Hatton had existent- much less elite- defensive skills; both of them led with their head and expected their will to carry them through the fight, as it had against their many lesser opponents. Gatti made a name for himself fighting action-packed fights with poor defensive fighters, most famously Micky Ward, and Hatton spent all but one other fight of his career at a weight class below Mayweather. Cotto has been in there with far better fighters than Gatti or Hatton, namely Manny Pacquiao and Shane Mosley (Mosley looked ancient when he fought Mayweather, he was 3 years younger when he fought Cotto). Neither Gatti nor Hatton could stay on the inside against Floyd, which is what action fighters like Gatti, Hatton, and Cotto like to do.


Cotto's size should give him the ability to stay on the inside against Mayweather.  He has to, otherwise he'll have no chance of winning the fight- Mayweather's reach is 5" longer (72-67). Unlike anybody Floyd has ever faced, Cotto is used to taking much bigger punches than the ones he'll be taking from Mayweather. Cotto's been in there with Margarito twice (including once with loaded gloves, undoubtedly the hardest hits he's ever taken), and Ricardo Mayorga, a powerful yet not particularly skilled fighter, both at 154 pounds.  On average, Cotto throws as much as twice as many punches per round as the more defensive-minded Mayweather. At 35, does Mayweather still have the reflexes to afford a low punch output, especially in a boxing climate where aggressiveness heavily weighs upon the scoring?  Mayweather is going to be forced to throw far more often than he is used to, which could either bring out the best offense we've seen from Mayweather since his days at 130 pounds or could bring out Floyd's flaws (very few of which we've seen, he's 42-0). 


Miguel Cotto is the best fighter that Floyd Mayweather has been in the ring with since he fought Jose Luis Castillo in 2002.  Most of his recent fights have had some angle that gives him the clear advantage. In order: Victor Ortiz had no business being in the ring with Floyd, there were far better fighters out there. Shane Mosely was several years past his prime. Juan Manuel Marquez was moving up from lightweight to welterweight, a 12 pound difference in weight classes, and Floyd purposely didn't make the 144-lb catchweight so he could outweigh Marquez by 5 pounds in the ring. Ricky Hatton was moving up a weight class, and Oscar De La Hoya was no closer to his prime than Mosley was. Those are Floyd's only boxing matches in the last five years. It's about time he chose to have a fight.