Tuesday, January 3, 2012

The Curious Case of Prince Fielder: Where He Winds Up and Why


            The Major League Baseball off-season has been unusual compared to recent years. Except for the four-day window where Albert Pujols, C.J. Wilson, Jose Reyes, and Mark Buehrle signed with the Angels and Marlins, respectively, there has been very little free agent movement over the last two months.  One international star looks like he will be signed (Yu Darvish), while another, Yoennis Cespedes, doesn't appear close. The Phillies and Marlins got their closers (Jonathan Papelbon, Heath Bell), and a few trades were made (Gio Gonzalez, Andrew Bailey, Mark Melancon), but no real headlines were made over signings like Dontrelle Willis to the Phillies or Octavio Dotel to the Tigers (minus the fact that it’s Dotel’s record-setting 13th team). A slow market has defined this off-season.  

            Several players who may have been signed earlier in other years remain on the market, most notably former Milwaukee Brewers 1B Prince Fielder.  This can be attributed to two main causes: the lack of big-market activity and the current trend in baseball to stress minor-league development.  Almost all of baseball’s traditional big-markets are not in the running for Prince: The Yankees have Teixeira locked up for 5 more years, the Red Sox have Adrian Gonzalez, the Phillies have Ryan Howard, the Angels just signed Pujols, and the Mets and Dodgers are both broke. The White Sox have been repeatedly burned with big contracts like Adam Dunn and Alexis Rios and most likely aren’t looking to add payroll. Teams like the Tampa Bay Rays and San Francisco Giants have proven that patience with young players can pay dividends and several teams, even the big-market Yankees, are following their examples. 

            Prince Fielder will sign with the Washington Nationals.  The Nationals, who made a big splash with Jayson Werth last year, have been looking to make another one this off-season. They’ve been in on C.J. Wilson and Mark Buehrle, and they reportedly offered Mark Teixeira 8 yrs/160 million prior to 2009. Washington’s opening day payroll in 2011 was 21st in the league, but the up-and-coming franchise is expecting big attendance boosts with a healthy Stephen Strasburg and the potential arrival of Bryce Harper. I expect the Nationals to offer somewhere between 7-10 years for between 22 and 24 million per, which given the contracts of Pujols, Howard, Gonzalez, and Teixeira, would fall right in line.  Given that the core of the Nationals team is young, relatively cheap (minus Jayson Werth), and locked up long-term, Prince Fielder would be a perfect fit for a club that finished 81-81, has added Gio Gonzalez, and expect Strasburg and star third-basemen Ryan Zimmerman to be healthy for all of 2012 (Strasburg only made 5 starts and Zim missed over 50 games).

            The other teams in on Prince Fielder include, in my order of likelihood, are the Blue Jays, Rangers, Orioles, Cubs, Mariners, Cardinals, Brewers. Barring a random offer that blows the Nationals out of the water, I can’t see any of these teams signing Prince.  One of these teams would have to step up and offer Prince a Pujols/A-Rod-like contract to have a chance at signing him.  The Rangers are putting a lot of money towards Yu Darvish, the Cardinals recently signed Carlos Beltran and have traditionally built from within, and the Brewers don’t have the money, otherwise they would have signed him already. The Cubs and new GM Theo Epstein are an interesting case. When the off-season started, I predicted that they would sign Prince but Epstein looks like he is taking the opposite approach and trying to completely re-build the Cubs from the bottom up.  As for the Orioles, Mariners, and Blue Jays? None of those teams are going anywhere fast and most likely are not willing to pay max dollar.