Wednesday, January 4, 2012

Manning, Luck, or Both?

There’s been a lot of debate recently over who the Colts quarterback should be in 2012.  Andrew Luck is assumed to be the number 1 overall pick, and Peyton Manning is supposed to be healthy again next season.  Monday’s firing of Bill and Chris Polian has sent the sports media into a frenzy over Manning’s future. The future Hall-of-Fame quarterback is due a $28 million bonus on March 8, about six weeks before the draft. The Colts will have to decide by then what to do with Manning, and, if they should keep or trade the number one pick.

If it appears that Peyton Manning will be ready to play come September 2012, the Colts have to keep him. And the Colts have to draft Andrew Luck.  Here’s why:

- Rule changes over the last few years have made quarterbacks more dominant than ever.  There are stats all over the place that back that statement up, but my favorite one is this: The top 5 finishers in passing yards all play for playoff teams. Their teams went a combined 60-20. Now take the leading passers on the worst three teams in the league- the Colts, Rams, and Vikings. Their leading passers finished 33rd, 27th, and 30th, respectively. There is more of a correlation between the ability to move the ball through the air and your chances of winning now than ever. Peyton Manning has finished outside the top three in passing yards only twice in his career. Guess what else he’s missed twice in his career? Yes, the playoffs.

-Another rule change affects this decision even greater. The new CBA’s rookie salary limits help the Colts tremendously. They can afford to keep both Manning and Luck on the roster without having to deplete the rest of their team.

-One option would be to keep Manning and trade the number one pick. But at age 35, Manning probably has no more than 3 good years left in him (assuming he’s healthy). And then what? Do the Colts find themselves scrambling for a new franchise quarterback? Ask the Redskins, Dolphins, Browns, Cardinals, or Jaguars how easy it is to find a franchise quarterback. When you have the opportunity to do it, you cannot pass it up. Why not draft your quarterback of the future? Andrew Luck can wait 1-2 years to play, like Aaron Rodgers or Steve Young. Who better to learn under than Peyton Manning?

-The other main option would be to draft Luck and trade/release Manning. This, I believe, would be the worst of the decisions. Could it turn out great? Yes. If Luck is the stud that everyone believes him to be, the Colts could make this move and never regret it. But, you cannot part with a great quarterback and automatically expect the pick to work out. How’s Tim Couch doing? Ryan Leaf? What about Sam Bradford? Even if Bradford becomes a great player like he has shown flashes of when healthy, he’s the perfect example of why you can’t bank on anyone in the NFL. If Luck ever went down like Bradford did this past year, would the Colts be contempt going 2-14 again? 

                I truly believe that Peyton Manning has good football left in him and that it would be a great mistake to let him go.  People seem to be quick to forget that before recent neck surgeries, Peyton had shown no signs of slowing down.  If he can play in 2012, I expect him to be in same class as Brees/Rodgers/Brady once again. More importantly for  the Colts, they’ll once again be a playoff team.