Friday, January 13, 2012

Initial Reactions to the Montero-Pineda Trade

I am thrilled with the Yankees acquisition of Michael Pineda.  In an American League that has seen the balance of power shift during free agency with the Angels pickups of CJ Wilson and Albert Pujols, the Yankees have elevated themselves into championship contention by acquiring their position of greatest need- another good starting pitcher to slot behind CC Sabathia.


Now they can line up CC, Pineda, Ivan Nova, and with the chance of Phil Hughes returning to All-Star form, that is a formidable starting rotation.  Besides, now AJ Burnett might not have a real role on the team, something Yankee fans have been begging for.  He'll be in a competition with Hughes and Freddy Garcia for a rotation spot, and anyone who watched the Yankees last year knows that Garcia pitched well above number 5 starter status. 


Some fans might be upset that the Yankees traded Jesus Montero, but in reality they Yankees have been dangling their top prospect for a few years now.  In fact, if they had been able to trade Montero for Cliff Lee in July 2010 like they were trying to before it fell through, it would be them and not the Texas Rangers who won the AL that year.  I never got the sense from Yankees management that they were as thrilled with Montero as the rest of baseball was.  How often does a team repeatedly include a top-5 prospect in baseball in every major trade offer, especially when the player is a power-hitting catcher? There were too many questions surrounding not only Montero's defense but also his attitude, and with other top catching prospects behind Montero (Austin Romine, Gary Sanchez), one of two things were bound to happen: either Montero would change positions or get traded.


Look at it this way.  Nobody expected Montero to be the Yankees full-time catcher in 2012, meaning he would be mainly be a DH who occassionally catches instead of Russell Martin.  First base isn't an option for the next five years- the length of Mark Teixeira's contract- and Montero in the outfield would be a disaster in the making.  So essentially, the Yankees traded a designated hitter for a legitimate number 2 starter who has the potential to be an ace. I don't care who's DHing, Jesus Christ or Jesus Montero, there is no DH in the league as valuable as a stud starting pitcher is.  All you have to do is look at the Yankees in last year's playoffs. No, I'm not talking about the fact that they didn't have enough quality starters. I'm talking about the fact that DH Jorge Posada played out of his mind, and the Yankees still lost.  If one starter had played as well as Posada did, the Yankees would have blown by Detroit. 


When a 6'7, 250+ pound hard-thrower comes to mind, who is it? For me, it's CC Sabathia, and now the Yankees have a right-hander of similar stature.  Pineda is very remiscent of Sabathia 10 years ago- in his 2011 rookie season, Pineda dominated for 2 months, struggled for a while, dominated for another stretch, then was average. This is exactly how CC's first few years in Cleveland went.  Unlike a young Sabathia, Pineda didn't have a high number of walks (55 in 171 innings), so, one might say he's ahead of where CC was in the early 2000s.  Pineda also struck out over a batter an inning last season, and with CC's strikeout rate dropping, this gives the Yankees their big punch-out starter.  As a Yankee fan, I am 10x more confident going into a 3-game series in Boston with Sabathia, Pineda, and Nova lined up to pitch.  Fans might argue that they didn't want to trade away a young prospect in Montero, but Pineda is only 22 and has an equally large number of great seasons ahead of him. 


I don't want to hear that Yankee fans are sentimental over trading their top prospect of the last few years. This is the same organization that let Bernie Williams, Jorge Posada, and countless others who had immensely more of an impact on the organization than Montero just walk out the door and never get an invite back. This isn't clearing the farm system like the Yankees repeatedly did for over a decade before realizing teams that developed younger players happened to be winning.  The Yankees are in a fortunate position of having an excess of premium catching prospects, and this trade clears way for Austin Romine and Gary Sanchez to progress through the system.  An excess of young players at the same position is an asset in the trade market, and I am glad the Yankees took advantage of it.

No comments:

Post a Comment