As a New Jersey resident and a college football fan, I was shocked to hear that the Tampa Bay Buccaneers hired Rutgers head football coach Greg Schiano. I don’t know what qualifies Schiano to be an NFL head coach. Not only is Schiano is one game over .500 in 10 seasons, but he hasn't been more than a defensive backs coach in the NFL, and that was only from 1996-98. Wins in the Pinstripe, St. Petersburg, PapaJohns.com, International, and Texas bowl aren't exactly resume builders. One good season in college- in 2006 Rutgers went 11-2- does not qualify anyone for an NFL head coaching job. His prior experience at Rutgers was as defensive coordinator at Miami, which couldn’t have been the toughest job considering he had Ed Reed, Dan Morgan (the best LB in the country in 2000), and Philip Buchannon, not to mention an offense that featured Clinton Portis, Reggie Wayne, Santana Moss, and Jeremy Shockey. When the offense scores 42 a game, the defense’s job becomes a helluva a lot easier.
Sure, Schiano took Rutgers from a perennial candidate for the worst team in the nation to mediocrity, but he had 10 years to do it. The highest paid public employee in the state of New Jersey (2.35 million/season) has failed to deliver on his promise to make Rutgers a national program. In 10 matchups, Rutgers has never beaten West Virginia, the only national program left in the Big East. The Big East in itself is about as average a conference as can be found in college football, and Schiano’s teams were average within it. Over his last 6 seasons he is a much-more impressive 49-28, but that number isn’t too impressive when you consider how weakened his conference has become.
During his time at Rutgers, he saw Big East powers Miami, Virginia Tech, and Boston College leave the conference, only to be replaced by a decent-at-best programs in Louisville and Cincinnati. The Big East is arguably the seventh best conference in college football, falling behind the SEC, Big-12, Pac-12, Big-10, ACC, and Mountain West. I have a tough time taking any argument that places them higher than 5th. Still, Schiano failed to make a school that had a bigger recruiting advantage than any of the teams left in the Big East into a serious national-scale team.
While he should win the recruiting battle every year, Rutgers has finished tops in the 8-team Big East in recruiting only once (rivals.com). He has consistently fallen behind some combination of West Virginia, Cincinnati, Louisville, and Pittsburgh without any legitimate reason as to why. Every other team in the Big East has its reasons to not attract the top talent in their state, but Rutgers is the only division 1 football program in NJ. The state of New Jersey features the nation’s best high school football program, Don Bosco, as well as a host of other talent. Rivals.com ranks NJ as the 10th best HS football state in the country (https://exmail.dickinson.edu/owa/redir.aspx?C=0e564a6c3c0546e0a57740e5dfe65b98&URL=http%3a%2f%2fhighschool.rivals.com%2fcontent.asp%3fCID%3d1290345). While that doesn’t sound too impressive, it does when you consider the location of the other schools in the Big East. Only Ohio (Cincinnati) ranks higher among states containing Big East schools, and they fall a distant second in recruiting to Ohio State. While Cincinnati has 5 New Jersey players on their roster, Rutgers has 0 players from Ohio on theirs. Pennsylvania (Pittsburgh) ranks 11th in HS football, but once again, they have Penn State to compete with in recruiting. West Virginia and Connecticut, both of whom have multiple Big East Championships in the last five seasons, rank 33rd and 41st, respectively.
Not only are there Schiano-related problems behind this hiring, but it also contradicts the model of success at the pro level. What wins in the NFL? Stability. Stability in the front office, stability at head coach, and stability at quarterback. The Pittsburgh Steelers are arguably the most successful organization in the NFL because they have had one ownership group and only three head coaches over the last 40+ years. The San Francisco 49ers had a great run in the 80s and well into the 90s because they had a GM/head coach (Bill Walsh) and quarterback (Joe Montana) that groomed their successors, George Seifert and Steve Young, maintaining the organizational stability. The Green Bay Packers of Brett Favre/Aaron Rodgers are the same way, and the modern-day Patriots have been the NFL's best team of the last 12 years because of their organizational stability. The Philadelphia Eagles have been successful, to a lesser extent, for the same reason. The Giants have been successful because Eli Manning and Tom Coughlin have grown together and have both become top-tier at their position.
The trend goes on and on, and the opposite argument holds true. Teams like the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Oakland Raiders, Washington Redskins, Cleveland Browns, and a handful of others will never have sustained winning in the NFL until they establish a solid foundation. How can they? They are competing against teams whose base has years of practice and experience together while they are trying to patch things together because of continual upheaval. Complete turnover doesn't work in the NFL. Ask Bobby Petrino and the Atlanta Falcons. Jim Harbaugh is the only recent college coach to be successful in the NFL, but he was mainly an NFL guy for the last 20-25 years and came into a situation with a team (especially defense) on the rise (Not to take anything away from Jim Harbaugh. He is a very good coach that is the outlier in the NCAA to NFL coaching trend). Schiano is walking into a dead end in Tampa Bay, an organization that thought signing Albert Haynesworth would be a solution to their problems.
For further, read here: http://espn.go.com/college-sports/recruiting/football/story/_/id/7506907/rutgers-scarlet-knight-recruits-wait-greg-schiano-never-arrives-meeting?eleven=twelve. Schiano couldn’t even let the kids know that he wouldn’t be coming? There goes Rutgers’ best recruiting class ever, as this year’s was the #1 ranking that I mentioned previously. Rutgers gave Schiano a shot (and upwards of $20 million) to become a head coach. And people wonder why New Jersey is known as a corrupt state. The least Schiano could do is show some class.
No comments:
Post a Comment