The timing of Jorge Posada’s retirement is not at all surprising. It is clear that the Yankees had no intention of re-signing Posada this off-season, especially not with the emergence of Jesus Montero. I don’t think that Posada’s tremendous ALDS against the Tigers changed Brian Cashman’s feelings on this for even a second- look how Hideki Matsui’s Yankee career ended. As modern-day Yankee fans, we’ve been trained to first think about what’s best for the club now, and anyone who saw Posada’s mostly abysmal 2011, Montero’s great September, or A-Rod’s growing need to DH would say that Posada’s departure is currently for the better. But a player with the significance of Jorge Posada does not go so quietly.
It’s tough for me to look at Posada and say that he’s a Hall-of-Famer. I was blessed enough to see Posada play roughly 100 times in person, and I can honestly say that not one of those times did I look at Posada and think “there’s a future Hall-of-Famer.” He spent his career overshadowed by Jeter, A-Rod, Bernie Williams, Jason Giambi, Mark Teixeira, Robinson Cano, Hideki Matsui, Gary Sheffield, Alfonso Soriano, Paul O’Neill, Tino Martinez, and that’s just on the offensive side. Posada spent his career catching David Wells, David Cone, Andy Pettitte, Roger Clemens, Mike Mussina, Randy Johnson, CC Sabathia, and of course, Mariano Rivera, all of whom had bigger profiles than Posada. He was rarely anyone's favorite player, in fact, of all the Yankee fans I know I can't think of anyone who would consider Posada their favorite player. But if there’s one thing I’ll always associate Posada with, it’s pride.
I’ll remember Posada as the constant Yankee. Unlike some of his higher-profile teammates, his effort and intensity were never questioned. His heart and his ability to put distractions aside when he was on the field was unmatched, as Posada spent several years with his son’s health in question. During his prime (2000-2007) Posada averaged 142 games a year, remarkable for a catcher. He averaged 23 HR, 90 RBI, hit .283 and had an impressive .389 on-base percentage during that 8-year span. In 2003, arguably his best all-around season, Posada came in 3rd in the AL MVP voting- only Joe Mauer (2009) and Ivan Rodriguez (1999) have finished higher amongst AL catchers over the last 35 years. 2003 was also the fourth year in a row in which Posada was named an All-Star and won the Silver Slugger award, honors that he would also win again in 2007. Even though his best friend Jeter has had the captain label since 2003, it was Posada who was the post-O’Neill/Martinez leader of the Yankees for the majority of the 2000s.
As a Yankee fan, Posada was always underappreciated until the last few years of his career. One of the biggest testaments that can be made about Posada is that in the only year that he was injured for most of it (2008), the Yankees missed the playoffs. His defense was often criticized- but it was the same defense that started on 4 World Series-winning teams and won 2 more pennants on top of that. A switch-hitting catcher with power and serviceable defense is about as much of a rarity as you’re going to find in baseball. While his departure won’t have an immediate impact on a club that should win 90+ games again next year, his loss will be felt in years to come, especially if Montero’s hustle or the team’s seeming lack of pride comes into question.
No comments:
Post a Comment